NW Recovery Centers Logo
News

Idaho's Fentanyl Trafficking Law Has Charged 134 People, Many Never Accused of Selling

A review of Idaho court records found 30 people charged with fentanyl trafficking without evidence of selling, under a law that bars drug court and parole.

8 min readBy NW Recovery Centers Editorial Team
A state capitol dome seen between bare autumn trees under soft afternoon light

Two years after Idaho began treating possession of four grams of fentanyl as trafficking, a review of the state's court records has counted 134 people charged under the law — and found that at least 30 of them were never accused of selling or distributing the drug.

The review, published Monday by the nonprofit newsroom InvestigateWest, examined every fentanyl trafficking case filed through June 30, 2026. In the 90 cases that included an arrest report, about one-third contained none of the evidence prosecutors usually use to show dealing — no scales, no ledgers, no small baggies — yet the defendants were charged with trafficking and faced the mandatory prison term attached to the amount of fentanyl police said they had.

One of them was Isaac Berger, arrested at a Moscow hospital in May 2025 after a nurse treating him for an overdose called police. His mother had brought the pills she found in his room to the emergency department, hoping they would help clinicians treat him. Berger became the first person in Latah County charged under the new law, and he died of fentanyl poisoning two months later while his case was still open.

The law removes discretion from the courtroom. It also forecloses the outcomes families ask about first.

What the law actually says

House Bill 406, effective July 1, 2024, added a section to the Idaho Code: § 37-2732D, "Trafficking in fentanyl — mandatory sentences." Anyone knowingly in actual or constructive possession of four grams or more of fentanyl, or — in pill form — 100 pills or more, is guilty of trafficking. Nine states allow trafficking charges based on a possession threshold; InvestigateWest reports Idaho is the only one where a pill count can substitute for weight.

The tiers are set by quantity:

  • 4 to under 14 grams, or 100 to under 250 pills: a mandatory minimum of three years and a fine of at least $10,000.
  • 14 to under 28 grams, or 250 to under 500 pills: five years and $15,000.
  • 28 grams or more, or 500 pills or more: ten years and $25,000.
  • Maximum: life in prison and a $100,000 fine. A second conviction doubles the mandatory minimum.

Subsection (c) is the part that changes what a family can hope for. Adjudication of guilt "shall not be suspended, deferred, or withheld," the person "shall not be eligible for parole prior to serving the mandatory minimum," and "the court shall not retain jurisdiction." In plain terms: no withheld judgment, no retained-jurisdiction rider, no early parole, and no judge free to sentence below the floor.

Two other clauses matter for people who are not dealers. Subsection (d) makes an agreement or conspiracy to commit the offense punishable as if the person had committed it. Subsection (e) provides that if the quantity a person is accused of representing is larger than the amount actually found, the represented quantity controls the charge.

The same bill created a drug-induced homicide charge

House Bill 406 did a second thing that drew less attention. It created § 37-2734D, drug-induced homicide.

A person is guilty if they violated the state's drug statutes and "provided a controlled substance to a person" who then dies from ingesting it. The penalty is "imprisonment for an indeterminate term of life" and a fine of up to $25,000.

The text does not carve out sharing. A person who hands a pill to a friend at a party, and that friend dies, is inside the definition.

What the Good Samaritan law covers, and what it does not

Idaho has had an overdose Good Samaritan statute since 2018. Section 37-2739C says that a person acting in good faith who seeks medical assistance for someone in a drug-related emergency — and the person experiencing the emergency — "shall not be charged or prosecuted."

But the statute names what it shields. The protection covers possession under § 37-2732(c) or (e), being under the influence under § 37-2732C(a), and drug paraphernalia under § 37-2734A(1). Section 37-2732D, the fentanyl trafficking offense enacted six years later, is not on that list.

That gap is the shape of the Berger case: an overdose patient in a hospital, reported by the nurse treating him, charged under the one section his state's immunity law does not mention.

Thirty cases with no dealing evidence

The InvestigateWest review found charges in 18 of Idaho's 44 counties, with six counties accounting for more than 75% of them. Bonneville County, near the Wyoming border, filed 28 — the most of any county — with one fentanyl trafficking conviction and 16 pleas to other charges. Ada County produced the most trafficking convictions. At least seven arrests began as traffic stops.

Of the completed cases, 30% were dismissed and nearly half ended in a plea to a different charge. Twenty-two people were convicted of fentanyl trafficking and are serving prison time; 40 people in total have served time after a trafficking conviction or a plea to an alternative charge. Families facing a prison term can find reentry guidance in our guide.

Thirteen people received substance use treatment instead of prison. All thirteen got there by pleading to a charge other than fentanyl trafficking — the mandatory minimums, as written, do not permit an alternative sentence.

Prosecutors who supported the law defend it. Bonneville County Prosecuting Attorney Randy Neal told InvestigateWest that "treatment is not the right outcome for every case" and that someone caught with four grams — "about four sugar packets" — is unlikely to be holding for personal use "because the numbers are so insane." Latah County Prosecuting Attorney Bill Thompson said the trafficking statutes let his office work around judges he considers lenient on dealers.

Kellen Russoniello, public health director at the Drug Policy Alliance, argued the threshold is easier to cross than prosecutors assume for someone with a high tolerance or a bulk purchase on payday. "This law is ensnaring people who are possessing for personal use," he said.

Deaths were already falling when the law took effect

Idaho's health department attributes 212 opioid overdose deaths to 2024, and reports that the state's fentanyl death rate doubled between 2020 and 2022.

The federal series shows what happened next. CDC's 12-month-ending counts for Idaho put deaths involving synthetic opioids other than methadone — the category that is mostly illicit fentanyl — at 200 for the year ending December 2023, 125 for 2024, and 119 for 2025. The rolling figure for the 12 months ending May 2026 is 103. Total overdose deaths in the same series fell from 367 to 326 to 294, and stood at 265 in the May 2026 window.

The 12 months ending December 2024 include only six months of the new law, and Idaho's decline in that window (37.5% in the synthetic-opioid category) was close to the national decline (34.3%). In the next window, Idaho's figure fell another 4.8% while the national figure fell 21%.

What the research says about deterrence

Republican Rep. Ted Hill and Sen. Todd Lakey, the bill's sponsors, argued in 2024 that harsher penalties would deter dealers. InvestigateWest reported that none of the prosecutors defending the law provided evidence for that claim.

The federal government's summary of the research is blunt. The National Institute of Justice's "Five Things About Deterrence" states that "increasing the severity of punishment does little to deter crime," partly because people who break the law "know little about the sanctions for specific crimes"; certainty of being caught matters more than severity.

What happens next

Thirty-one of the 134 cases remain pending. Idaho's legislature meets in January, and the statute can be amended without touching the trafficking tiers — adding § 37-2732D to the Good Samaritan list, or restoring discretion for possession-only cases, would not require repeal.

For families in Idaho, four things are worth knowing:

  • The quantity sets the charge, not the intent. Four grams or 100 pills is the line; nothing in the statute requires proof of a sale.
  • A plea is currently the only route to treatment. Thirteen people got there by pleading to a different charge — a decision to make with an attorney, not in a first conversation with a prosecutor, and one that shapes what court-ordered treatment looks like afterward.
  • The Good Samaritan law protects possession and use. It does not name the trafficking section. Anyone calling 911 should still call — naloxone and an ambulance save lives — but should not assume the shield reaches every charge.
  • Naloxone remains legal and available. The Idaho Department of Health and Welfare lists where to get it, and anyone in the state can request a prescription; our guide to getting naloxone walks through the pharmacy conversation.

Where to get help

The SAMHSA National Helpline is 1-800-662-4357, free and confidential, 24 hours a day; the 988 Lifeline answers calls and texts at 988. FindTreatment.gov lists licensed programs by ZIP code, and the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare publishes naloxone locations and training.

Sources