Redlined Neighborhoods Still Have Far Higher Opioid Death Rates, Massachusetts Study Finds
Massachusetts census tracts graded worst on 1930s redlining maps had 86% higher opioid overdose death rates, a new peer-reviewed study in Boston finds.

Massachusetts census tracts that the federal government graded worst on 1930s redlining maps had an 86% higher adjusted rate of opioid-related overdose deaths between 2015 and 2019 than tracts that received the best grade, according to a peer-reviewed study published in the November issue of the Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved.
The gap did not appear only at the extremes. Compared with the best-graded tracts, the five-year annual overdose death rate was 53% higher in neighborhoods rated "still desirable" and 61% higher in those rated "declining" — a stepwise gradient that ran in the same direction as the map itself. The paper, "Ninety Years Later: Redlining and Opioid-Related Overdose Deaths among Massachusetts Residents, 2015–2019," was written by a team led by Boston Medical Center researchers, with Becky Smeltzer, a doctoral student at the University of Southern California, as first author and addiction specialist Avik Chatterjee as senior author.
What the study actually measured
The researchers did not simply lay a 1930s map over a modern death map. They assigned redlining grades to 2010 census tracts using a weighting method, then linked five years of decedent records — 2015 through 2019 — to census tract population estimates.
They modeled the relationship with negative binomial regression, adjusted for demographics and for each tract's social vulnerability, and accounted for the fact that neighboring tracts tend to resemble one another by estimating robust standard errors for spatial autocorrelation, which the paper reports as significant at p<.001. The adjusted incidence rate ratios were 1.53 for "still desirable" tracts (95% CI 1.03–2.28), 1.61 for "declining" tracts (95% CI 1.07–2.43), and 1.86 for "hazardous" tracts (95% CI 1.18–2.93).
The authors are direct about what this is and is not. Their conclusion is that historical redlining "was associated with current opioid-related overdose deaths, exemplifying the enduring effects of historical racialized policy and structural disinvestment." It is a correlation measured across neighborhoods, not a claim that a lending map caused any individual death.
Why a 1930s map still tracks 2015 deaths
The Home Owners' Loan Corporation, a federal agency, produced color-coded maps in the 1930s that rated neighborhoods for loan risk. Areas were marked green, blue, yellow, or red — "hazardous" — and the ratings frequently followed the race or national origin of the people living there. The practice was outlawed by the Fair Housing Act of 1968. The disinvestment it locked in was not.
That is the mechanism the study is testing. Neighborhoods denied mortgage capital accumulated less home equity, fewer businesses, thinner primary care, and worse housing stock — conditions that shape who has access to treatment, naloxone, and stable housing decades later. Smeltzer described that continuity to MassLive this week: "These community conditions continue to exist today, increasing risk for overdose death as well as other negative health outcomes among the populations who are living there."
Chatterjee said the research question came out of fieldwork. While working with 16 Massachusetts communities in the HEALing Communities Study, the largest overdose prevention program funded by the National Institutes of Health, community members kept raising the same observation: "Community members were sort of noticing that it seemed to be that in certain neighborhoods, these overdose deaths were clustering."
The money question
The study lands while Massachusetts decides how to spend more than a billion dollars. The Attorney General's Office reports that it has secured more than $1 billion in eligible opioid-related recoveries, of which more than $390 million had been received as of its most recent accounting, with funds directed to the Commonwealth's Opioid Recovery and Remediation Fund and distributed to cities and towns.
The researchers argue that geography should be a factor in those decisions. They highlight two local efforts: Holyoke, which directed $25,000 in American Rescue Plan funding to Tapestry Health for outreach in predominantly Puerto Rican neighborhoods with high overdose rates, and Brockton, where the Brockton Neighborhood Health Center put a Cape Verdean community health worker on a mobile unit as overdose deaths rose among Cape Verdean residents.
How quickly municipal money moves is a separate question. MassLive reported that municipalities had received about $113.7 million by the end of fiscal year 2025 and had reported spending roughly $19.8 million — about 17% — citing data obtained by the Boston Institute for Nonprofit Journalism. Those figures come from a newsroom analysis, not from the state, and they describe municipal funds only, not the statewide fund.
For families and local boards sitting on unspent allocations, the practical takeaway from the paper is narrower than "spend faster": overdose risk in Massachusetts is not evenly distributed within a city, and a grant program that counts dollars per municipality can miss the tracts where the deaths are concentrated.
Deaths are falling — unevenly
The backdrop makes the finding harder, not easier, to act on. Provisional federal data show opioid-involved deaths in Massachusetts falling sharply: the 12-month-ending count was 924 as of June 2026, against a peak of 2,365 in 2023. Total drug overdose deaths over the same 12-month window were 1,297, down from a peak of 2,673. The CDC cautions that these counts are provisional, that 6% of recent records were still pending investigation, and that recent months are underreported due to incomplete data.
A falling statewide total can hide a widening gap. MassLive reported that state Department of Public Health data for 2023 showed Black residents with the highest rates of opioid-related deaths while the death rate for white men fell 16%, and that a Boston Globe analysis of death records found the overdose death rate among Black men over 55 rose 242% between 2017 and 2023. Chatterjee told the outlet some of the most recent data is beginning to show a reprieve in Black communities.
What to watch next
Three things are worth tracking from here.
First, whether the state's settlement dashboard and municipal reporting begin to break spending down by census tract or neighborhood rather than by city — the unit at which the study finds risk concentrating. Our guide to reading your county's overdose data covers where those local figures come from and how to hold them against the rhetoric. Second, whether the Opioid Recovery and Remediation Fund adopts any geographic targeting criteria tied to historical redlining grades or current social vulnerability, which would be a direct policy response to the paper. Third, whether similar analyses are run in other states; the method depends on two things most states have — HOLC maps and geocoded death records — so Massachusetts is unlikely to be the last.
The study's own closing argument is about who sits at the table: for settlement funds to be reparative, the authors write, Black and Hispanic people with lived experience must be at the center of the conversation.
Where to get help
- SAMHSA National Helpline — 1-800-662-4357, free, confidential, 24/7, English and Spanish.
- 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline — call or text 988.
- Massachusetts Behavioral Health Help Line — 833-773-2445, 24/7 for mental health and substance use needs.
- Find a treatment bed — findtreatment.gov, or call the SAMHSA line and ask for a bed check.
Naloxone remains available at pharmacies in Massachusetts without a prescription, and the state's standing order means you can ask a pharmacist directly. If you use drugs, do not use alone, and carry naloxone — the neighborhoods with the highest historical risk are also the ones where reversing an overdose fastest matters most.
Sources
- Smeltzer RP et al. — Ninety Years Later: Redlining and Opioid-Related Overdose Deaths among Massachusetts Residents, 2015–2019 (J Health Care Poor Underserved, Nov 2026; PMID 42969128)
- CDC — VSRR Provisional Drug Overdose Death Counts (Massachusetts, 12 month-ending)
- Massachusetts Attorney General's Office — opioid settlement recoveries and fund distribution
- SAMHSA National Helpline
You might also read


