NW Recovery Centers Logo
News

Oregon and Washington Sue Over Medicaid Work Rules as the Jan. 1 Deadline Nears

Oregon, Washington, Minnesota and New Mexico sued Nov. 5 over H.R. 1 Medicaid work rules, six days after a judge voided CMS's narrow 'medically frail' test.

8 min readBy NW Recovery Centers Editorial Team
Editorial illustration of a state outline, legislative documents and a coverage network with an accessibility ramp

On Nov. 5, the attorneys general of Oregon, Washington, Minnesota and New Mexico filed a federal lawsuit arguing that the Medicaid work requirement Congress created in H.R. 1 — the 2025 budget law the administration calls the One Big Beautiful Bill Act — is an unconstitutional condition on federal Medicaid money. Filed in federal court in Eugene, Oregon, it asks a judge to bar the government from cutting off existing Medicaid funding to states that fall short.

The filing is the second front in a fight that has moved through the courts all autumn. Six days earlier, on Oct. 29, a federal judge in Massachusetts struck down the narrowest piece of the administration's implementation: the test that decided who counts as too sick to work. That ruling helps people in addiction treatment prove they are exempt. It did not touch the requirement itself, and it did not move the Jan. 1, 2027 start date.

The regional stakes are arithmetic. Oregon's Attorney General says 564,177 Oregonians are enrolled in the Oregon Health Plan through the Affordable Care Act's Medicaid expansion, and the Oregon Health Authority estimates up to one-third of them may lose coverage under the new rules. In Washington, the filing puts more than 600,000 Apple Health members under the requirement, and cites the Washington Health Care Authority's estimate that at least 20% of them — about 120,000 people — may lose coverage.

What the four states are arguing

The complaint does not dispute that Congress can attach strings to federal money. It argues that this string is different in kind. H.R. 1, the states write, "overlaid a novel eligibility system that imposes a work requirement on expansion enrollees" without repealing the expansion itself, "under the guise of merely amending it" — a shift "in kind, not merely degree" in what Medicaid is for.

That matters because of a line of Supreme Court cases barring Congress from using its spending power as a "bludgeon" against states. The complaint leans on NFIB v. Sebelius, the 2012 Affordable Care Act decision, for three rules: states cannot be surprised by conditions imposed after they accepted the money, conditions must relate to the program's purpose, and the offer must leave them "a legitimate choice." Because H.R. 1 conditions the states' existing Medicaid funds — not new grant money — on compliance, the states say no real choice is left.

They ask for a declaration that the arrangement is unconstitutional and an injunction against withholding funds under 42 U.S.C. § 1396c.

The win that came six days earlier

The Oct. 29 decision, Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz, was a partial win for two dozen states and the District of Columbia, which had sued in June over the interim final rule CMS published on June 3 (91 Fed. Reg. 33348).

Three provisions were at issue. The first was the definition of "medically frail." Congress listed five exemption categories in the statute — blind or disabled, substance use disorder, a disabling mental disorder, a physical, intellectual or developmental disability that significantly impairs daily activities, and a serious or complex medical condition. CMS's rule added a second step: a person also had to show that their condition "significantly impairs the individual's ability to comply with the community engagement requirement." Judge Richard G. Stearns held that extra step contrary to law, vacated the language, and issued a permanent injunction, with a six-month stay of enforcement to give states time to change their verification systems.

The other two provisions survived. The court upheld CMS's limit on using claims data older than twelve months to verify frailty, and its restrictions on self-attestation, finding the agency's rationale was not arbitrary. It also noted that the states had not asked to extend the Jan. 1, 2027 deadline, and that the court could not have granted that relief anyway.

KFF's read, published Nov. 2, is that the ruling applies nationwide and should mean fewer people lose coverage over paperwork, while leaving most of the administrative burden in place. States may accept self-attestation of frailty in 2027; the scrutiny of individual patients by providers that many clinicians feared is mostly a 2028 question. HHS has not said whether it will appeal.

Who is exempt — and where the risk actually sits

The statutory requirement is 80 hours a month of work, school, community service or a combination, or a low income threshold that Washington sets at $580 a month in household modified adjusted gross income. Washington's exemption list adds people under 19, people on Medicare, people enrolled in another Medicaid program, and four short-term hardships — two that must be requested (travel outside the community for care of a serious condition; a hospital, nursing home or psychiatric inpatient stay) and two that apply automatically (living in a presidentially declared disaster area, or in a county with unemployment at least 1.5 times the national rate).

A substance use disorder is on the statutory exemption list, which is the single most important sentence here for our readers. But an exemption is not a switch that flips by itself. It has to be claimed and verified — and the provisions the court upheld govern that verification.

The twelve-month lookback is the sharp edge. CMS itself acknowledged in the rule that "reliable claims information may not be available to the State for individuals who are medically frail," particularly right after a new diagnosis when claims data lag. That argument did not persuade the court to strike the limit, which means someone whose treatment began fourteen months ago, or whose care was billed under an unusual code, may find the exemption harder to document than expected.

What this means if you or someone you love is in treatment

Nothing changes before Jan. 1, 2027. No one loses Oregon Health Plan or Apple Health coverage because of this lawsuit, and no one has to re-prove anything this month.

Between now and then, the practical work is paperwork that most people do badly and too late:

  • Update your address and phone with the state. Washington says members with current contact information will receive notices about the requirements and their renewal dates; a wrong address is how people lose coverage they were entitled to keep.
  • Ask your treatment provider for documentation now. A letter or record showing the diagnosis and the dates of care is the difference between an exemption granted and one denied for lack of proof. Keep it with your renewal notice.
  • Learn the exemption categories for your state. Oregon and Washington both publish their lists; Washington also offers an online H.R. 1 work requirements survey, and a sample notice in eight languages.
  • If you are meeting the requirement rather than claiming an exemption, keep proof — pay stubs, enrollment letters, volunteer logs. Washington requires you to show you met it in the month before you apply, or in any month during your certification period.
  • If a renewal is denied, appeal. Both states' releases are explicit that people are losing coverage for missing paperwork, not for ineligibility.

Rural counties are the place to watch: both attorneys general point to higher Medicaid use and higher unemployment there, which means more people subject to the rule and more facilities whose finances depend on the coverage.

What's next

The Oregon case has no hearing date yet. A preliminary injunction, if granted, would stop the government from withholding funds while the case proceeds — but the January deadline stands unless a court acts before then.

Meanwhile the administrative machinery keeps moving. CMS has issued detailed guidance on implementing the frailty exemption, including tiered frameworks that KFF expects states to keep building until it is clear the Massachusetts decision will hold. Oregon's governor signed Executive Order 26-27 on Oct. 13 directing state agencies to protect coverage, in a state where roughly 97% of residents are insured.

For families in Oregon and Washington, the honest summary is this: the requirement is still coming, the safety valve for people with a substance use disorder is real, and the thing that will decide most individual cases is whether the paperwork arrives on time. If you are in treatment, or your child or parent is, start collecting that documentation now — not in December.

Where to get help

The SAMHSA National Helpline is free, confidential and open 24 hours a day at 1-800-662-4357, with treatment options at findtreatment.gov. For a mental health or substance use crisis, call or text 988. For a medical emergency, call 911.

For questions about coverage, Oregon Health Plan members can find renewal information through the Oregon Health Authority at oregon.gov/oha, and Apple Health members in Washington can use the Health Care Authority's work requirements page and survey. Our guide to Medicaid and addiction treatment explains what the program covers, and our walkthrough on verifying insurance coverage shows how to confirm benefits. We also covered Indiana's parallel rollout in October.

Sources